Some fo these groups falsely profess to be christian while others openly represent nonchristian religions. The young adults protested the violation of their civil liberties with the help of lawyers provided by their chosen. The link between cults and brainwashing was widely discussed in the mid1970s. Deprogramming is the more drastic of the two approaches because it usually involves an initial kidnapping to get the cult member away from the cult. A friendofafriend invites you to a free vegan brunch. They appear nevertheless unable 0% unwilling to spell out any. Pdf on nov 1, 2014, suzanne newcombe and others published cults. Apr 06, 2016 here are a few techniques that are used by cults to brainwash people. Other brainwashing issues in the 1970s and the apparent success of deprogram. Sociologists david bromley and anson shupe initially defined the acm in 1981 as a collection of groups embracing brainwashing theory, but later observed a significant shift in ideology. Religion news blog rnb logs current and archived news about religious cults, sects, alternative religions and related issues.
New religious movements, cults, new age and related phenomena. A survey of cults and world religions jude ministries. Surely my sweet, reasonable, and intelligent daughter would never join such a group in her right mind. The growth of human potential cults in the 60s and 70s brought brainwashing to the media, and an industry of deprogrammers kidnapped teenagers and young adults from selfstyled communities in an attempt to save them. Soon after the hearst trial, in 1977, a pop book advocating the use of brainwashing terminology against new religions was authored by california psychiatrist paul a.
Cults are generally considered to be secretive and illegitimate whereas religion is open and legitimate. The vast majority of links are to essays and sites appear to believe in the effectiveness and. The primary pedagogical challenges involve motivating students to go beyond what is easy for them and helping students realize their own assumptions, context, and situatedness. Advocacy by scholars in the field of new religious movements emerged during the cult wars, which in the u. New religious movements are typically seen as cults by traditional religious groups, and brainwashing is often used as a way to describe the only possible reason that somebody would join one. Aug 01, 2012 this is the fourth in an eightpart series on how to identify brainwashing in a destructive group or cult. Combating cults and brainwashing in the united states and. Netflix has a special on the family not the cult listed here which will discuss the group founded by abraham vereide, operating in the united states for some 80 years. Since the late 1980s, though a significant public belief in cultbrainwashing remains, the academic communityincluding scholars from psychology, sociology, and religious studieshave shared an almost unanimous consensus that the coercive persuasion brainwashing thesis proposed by margaret singer and her colleagues in the 1980s is without.
The religious cult member must learn to adopt the peculiar reasoning processes and beliefs known as a cult group perspective. This is the first part of a twopart article on the concept of brainwashing in the study of new religious movements nrms. Introduction the fourth volume of sects, cults and new religions contains articles and chapters about how people engage with relationships in new religions, with emphasis on sexual and family. The best defense is educating children about the dangers of manipulative people and the techniques they use. A cult demands subservience to the leader that is achieved through coercion or brainwashing.
Richardson, a critique of brainwashing claims about new religious movements, 16066. Advocacy focused on the question of whether the cults used a persuasion technique known as brainwashing. Cult brainwashing cases and freedom of religion james t. List of many religious groups that profess false doctrine andor deny essential christian truth. A small religious group that is not part of a larger and more accepted religion and that has beliefs regarded as extreme or dangerous 3. The literature on cults split between cult sympathizers believe cults merely represent alternative culture describe cults as new religious movements see negativity toward cults as a reflection of prejudice and a symptom of moral panic and cult critics maintain cults are psychologically harmful.
Cults and brainwashing are more common than you might think. A frequent form of religious conversion nowadays is enroll ment in a cult or some version of new age religion. Jan 27, 2017 books about cults and oppressive religious groups. Since the horror of jonestown, religious cults have been a frequent sub. The effects of indoctrination and brainwashing from a cult or religion can last a lifetime, even if the victim is able to wake up from its severe mental grasp. Deprogramming, brainwashing and the medicalization of. Brainwashing and the persecution of cults springerlink. Nov 05, 2014 cults, religion, and brainwashing 1k20 chris stiff c. Originally published in barker, eileen 2010 the cult as a social problem. Cesnur brainwashing and mind control controversies. Christianity, cults and religions is an excellent short overview with brief summaries of the beliefs and basic history of 20world religions, sects, cults, and new religious movements. Generally, it is a group that is unorthodox, esoteric, and has a devotion to a person, object, or a set of new ideas.
This sense of the term is controversial and it has divergent definitions both in popular culture and academia and it has also been an ongoing source of contention among scholars across several fields of. Eight ways to identify religious brainwashing part 1 of 8 karen june 24, 2012 at 5. Not surprisingly, brainwashing theories are hotly contested by socalled cult apologists usually academic defenders of groups and movements generally identified as coercive cults. Combating cults and brainwashing in the united states and western europe.
Hadden association for the sociology of religion, society for the scienti. Overcoming the charisma of cult leaders, such as jim jones, is not an easy task. Christianity, cults and religions also available as pdf, and ebook. Religious extremism is a reaction to the perceived chaos and. Cults are joined through coercive persuasion whereas religion is generally inherited. Richardson cult cases have attracted considerable attention from the legal profession, scholars in several disciplines, the media, and the general public in recent years, as different types of legal action have been initiated involving new religions popularly called cults as parties.
To obtain permission to use this article beyond the scope of your. When the worlds most controversial guru builds an utopian city deep in the oregon country, conflict with the locals escalates into a national scandal. More groups will be added in the weeks and months ahead. Difference between cult and religion difference between. When i was a little kid 34 years, i suffered significant abuse from my parents. Breese, dave, know the marks of cults, the 12 basic errors of false religion, wheaton. A religious organization which caused panic in japan, especially in the mid nineties, was the cult aum shinrikyo. Perhaps the most important result of being converted to a religious cult is. A documentary about a man who impersonates a wise indian guru and builds a.
Big brother cults define what were not a common tactic is to define a big enemy in the outside world. Those who favour the term cultpredominantly support the brainwashing theories. The concept of brainwashing came into popular existence in the 1950s. Cults, religion, and brainwashing 1k20 chris stiff c. According to the anti cult cult awareness network, a cult is a closed system. See generally 19781 3 internal revenue manual exempt orgs. Christianity, cults and religions the most uptodate comparison chart from a christian perspective available in print. Effects of brainwashing and cults essay example graduateway. What are the brain washing techniques used by cults. Piercing the religious veil of the socalled cults core. Controversies over mind control by cults entail a redefinition of certain deviant religious move ments as induced mental pathologies which require an expansion of the jurisdiction of the medi cal profession. The search text of this pdf is generated from uncorrected ocr text. Some see brainwashing as a plausible explanation of why people join and remain in cults or in other abusive relationships. In modern english, a cult is a social group that is defined by its unusual religious, spiritual, or philosophical beliefs, or by its common interest in a particular personality, object or goal.
Dvdbased study for individuals or groups christianity. Our hope is that the information presented in this article is explained clearly and becomes a source of help to anyone brave enough to consider reprogramming their mind in order to find. Pdf new religious movements, cults, new age and related. Cults, brainwashing, and countersubversion sage journals. Hearst and in other cases involving brainwashing allegations against cults. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Brainwashing theories in european parliamentary and administrative reports on cults and sects. As one persons cult is likely to be another persons religion, sturdy boundaries. With deepest respect for those who have experienced true brainwashing, i mean no disrespect. Brainwashing is said to reduce its subjects ability to think critically or independently, to allow the introduction of new, unwanted thoughts and ideas into their minds. Brainwashing is an inherently subjective metaphor that is used as a rationale for persecuting unpopular movements and defining religious converts as nonautonomous zombies who can be.
Latest posts by manisha kumar see all difference between on and in march 18, 2010. During the 1980s and early 1990s, groups in the anti cult movement acm promoted the belief that cults were engaged in advanced forms of psychological manipulation of their members. Debunking the myth of religious brainwashing stand. Eight ways to identify religious brainwashing part 1 of 8 posted by steve smith on june 24, 2012 in uncategorized aki ray, a former childsoldier in cambodia, is now one of the worlds foremost mineclearing experts. In fact, cult leaders often attend anti cult meetings and conferences to try and learn about the latest, preventative measures and treatments. On the other hand, sect is a subset of major religions with some difference in viewpoints. Database of archived news items on brainwashing includes items added between oct. Combating cults and brainwashing in the united states. Cultbrainwashing cases and freedom of religion journal. But even more surprising, is how the anticult movement in israel has managed to harness state branches towards its rising activities over the past few years, so much so that it has placed israel in the most combative end of. Advocacy, brainwashing theories, and new religious movements. They are variants of wellknown social psychological principles of compliance, conformity, persuasion, dissonance, reactance, framing, emotional manipulation, and others that are used on all of us daily to entice us. Brainwashing is said to reduce its subjects ability to think critically or independently, to allow the introduction of.
Cultbrainwashing cases and freedom of religion oxford. A religious organization which caused panic in japan, especially in the midnineties, was the cult aum shinrikyo. Education about how brainwashing techniques and mind control techniques actually work is vital if we are to stop cults and psychopaths from destroying society. Lewis is an extensively published scholar of new religious movements and the new age.
After all, the religion clauses of the first amendment forbid government from preferring some religions over others, and from interfering in a persons religious practice. This book appeared at a time when the cults of the 60s and 70s were at their peak. Brainwashing and cultic mind control oxford handbooks. In a book by walter martin, the kingdom of the cults he indicates that a. Talkbeliefs interviews alexandra on her life in a cult, methods of brainwashing, what constitutes a cult, and how to educate the public on how to spot the warning signs of cult activity. Schein brainwashing is a colloquial term which has been used in reference to the systematic efforts of the chinese communists and by implication the soviets to persuade nonbelievers to accept communist allegiance, commands, andor doctrine by coercive means. Difference between sect and cult compare the difference. The 1984 israeli use of hypnosis law is the first of its kind in the world. To do this they have to make you feel unsure about who you are.
Dec 17, 2002 the notion of brainwashing as an anti. The use of this term has become so emotionally charged that scholars find it difficult to discuss. The controversy surrounding new religious movements seems to be foremost concerned with whether or not the members of these religions come of their own freewill or if they convert as a necessary and inevitable response to advanced brainwashing techniques used by the cult leaders. Is religious indoctrination a form of brainwashing. Religious deprogramming and subjective reality csun. Cults and brainwashing the ideology of cults, brainwashing, and mind control.
Since the late 1980s, though a significant public belief in cult brainwashing remains, the academic communityincluding scholars from psychology, sociology, and religious studieshave shared an almost unanimous consensus that the coercive persuasion brainwashing thesis proposed by margaret singer and her colleagues in the 1980s is without. Robert jay liftons eightpoint model of thought reform and borrows from several other authorities on the topic of religious mindcontrol. Although hearst was convicted, many observers viewed her sympathetically as a victim of brainwashing by terrorists. Online texts about cults and new religions stichting skepsis. The media enjoys covering daunting feature stories of cults, exploitative gurus, and brainwashing. Films about cults, religious fanaticism and brainwashing. For this reason, deprogramming is a very expensive service. This is the fourth in an eightpart series on how to identify brainwashing in a destructive group or cult. I give it four stars because it is dated, but it is important history nonetheless. Sociologist max weber 18641920 found that cults based on charismatic leadership often follow the routinization of charisma.
This work is not divided by chapters on cults but rather takes each verse of scripture that the cults may. In his book, know the marks of cults dave breese defines a cult in this way, a cult is a religious perversion. The literature on cults split between cult sympathizers believe cults merely represent alternative culture describe cults as new religious movements see negativity toward cults as a reflection of prejudice and a symptom of moral panic and cult critics maintain cults. A critique of brainwashing evidence in light of daubert. Becker as an expansion of german theologian ernst troeltschs churchsect typology. Maybe the new guy at work asks you to play bass in his indie rock band. In 1997, heavens gate cult leader marshall applewhite had a heartattack, claimed to have a near death experience, in hospital formed a bond with hes nurse, they decided they were the 2 witnesses described in the bible formed the cult combo of new age and scifi thought convinced 39 followers to commit suicide so their souls could ride on a spaceship they thought was hiding behind. The concept of a cult as a sociological classification was introduced in 1932 by american sociologist howard p. Their techniques were called brainwashing, thought reform, coercive persuasion, totalism, and mind control. A remarkable thing about cult mind control is that its so ordinary in the tactics and strategies of social influence employed. Zeller in this fascinating overview, benjamin zeller not only explores the question of why the members of heavens gate committed ritual suicides, but interrogates the origin and evolution of the religion, its appeal, and its practices. Beware of political cult groups that manipulate and. It is a belief and practice in the world or religion which calls for devotion to a religious view or leader centered in false doctrine. Saner, emin 2012 i was a moonie cult leader, the guardian, monday 3.
It is a clear and documented explanation of how and why brainwashing works, its history, its dangers, and its potential benefits. While the presence of authoritarian cults in our midst raises a number of social control and law and order issues, current controversies over cults contain substantial elements of mystification. There is a large literature on cults, but it is sharply divided along ideological grounds with those who are opposed to cults often, but not always, on religious grounds obviously finding fault with the ideologies of cults as well as their practices and recruiting devices. The moonies and the children of god primarily promote themselves as religious. Science and unpopular religions, coauthored with gerald ginsburg, and a social psychological critique of brainwashing claims about recruitment to new religions. New religious movements, brainwashing, mind control, communist thought reform, robert lifton, cult stereotype james r. Academic approaches the literature on cults split between cult sympathizers believe cults merely represent alternative culture describe cults as new religious movements see negativity toward cults as a reflection of prejudice and a symptom of moral panic and cult critics. Understanding cults and new religions understanding world.
Christianity, cults and religions will help you know what you believe and why. Brainwashing also known as mind control, menticide, coercive persuasion, thought control, thought reform, and reeducation is the concept that the human mind can be altered or controlled by certain psychological techniques. Religious extremism and the search for meaning theo 301 draft syllabus dr. Deprogramming, brainwashing and the medicalization of deviant.
443 717 1589 618 950 544 652 148 857 810 1195 578 186 268 1592 723 508 218 1077 58 448 1563 928 1343 689 1441 1581 751 780 1269 1410 1059 481 206 589 113 71 375 1302